Home Entertainment Reality Test: The Kashmir Recordsdata and the disinformation surrounding it

Reality Test: The Kashmir Recordsdata and the disinformation surrounding it

Reality Test: The Kashmir Recordsdata and the disinformation surrounding it

Sharing is caring!

Debunking some claims on Kashmiri Pandits and The Kashmir Recordsdata, a film based mostly on them

Debunking some claims on Kashmiri Pandits and The Kashmir Recordsdata, a film based mostly on them

The Kashmir Recordsdata, a current Bollywood film based mostly on the exodus of Kashmiri Pandits in the course of the nineties has offered fodder for varied false and deceptive information. Directed by Vivek Ranjan Agnihotri and starring Anupam Kher and Pallavi Joshi amongst others, the film has been made tax-free in a number of States. It has additionally has rekindled the talk on militancy within the erstwhile State.

Listed here are some claims circulating within the social media in regards to the film and the so-called repurcussions it has created.

Rhode Island formally recognised “Kashmir Genocide”?

It is a declare by the director himself. He had tweeted on March 14 that Rhode Island, a State in USA, Rhode Island, “has formally recognised Kashmir Genocide on account of a really small movie.”

(Here is the archived tweet)

A better have a look at the quotation he shared would tell us that there is no such thing as a point out of the phrase genocide.

Additionally Learn

Journalist Raqib Hameed Naik reached out to Brian Patrick Kennedy, State Consultant, Rhode Island and posted his response. “The quotation from the State was to easily acknowledge the premiere of this film,” Mr. Kennedy wrote including that “a quotation is solely the acknowledgement of a particular occasion. It does NOT maintain weight of a Decision permitted by the members of the Home.”

Reality Test: False.

What number of Kashmiri Pandits have been killed within the Valley?

An reply from Srinagar Police Headquarters was being extensively circulated with a declare that solely 89 Kashmiri Pandits have been killed since 1990. Comparable claims could be learn here, here, and here.

The picture is real. Hindi newspaper Dainik Bhaskarpublished an article in regards to the RTI. The article mentions the info was of 31 years, that’s from January 1990. However the first indicators of militancy in Kashmir began in 1988 and the primary main assault was in September 1989 with the homicide of distinguished Kashmiri Pandit lawyer and BJP chief Tika Lal Taploo. This, and a number of other different assaults weren’t coated within the RTI question.

To a query posed by the then Rajya Sabha member Amar Singh, the MHA on 20.12.2017 mentioned: “As per the report of State Authorities of Jammu and Kashmir, 174 circumstances of killing of Kashmiri Pandits by terrorists have been registered by the Jammu and Kashmir Police.”

In 2010, The Hindureported that the Jammu and Kashmir Meeting was knowledgeable that 219 Kashmiri Pandits have been killed by militants since 1989 whereas 24,202 households have been among the many complete 38,119 households which migrated out of the Valley on account of turmoil. Shujaat Bukhari, the correspondent who wrote the story, was killed by terrorists in Srinagar on June 14, 2018.

Whereas there are discripancies over the numbers talked about by varied companies, it’s sure that greater than 89 Pandits, and scores of others misplaced their lives to terror.

Reality examine: Deceptive

Did BJP leaders break down after watching the film?

An old image of an emotional L.K. Advani is being circulated with a false claim.

An previous picture of an emotional L.Okay. Advani is being circulated with a false declare.
| Photograph Credit score: Particular Association

A video of L.Okay. Advani turning emotional throughout a film screening, and one other certainly one of Uttar Pradesh Chief Minister Yogi Adityanath on tears went viral claiming it was their response after watching The Kashmir Recordsdata.

Mr. Advani did flip emotional after watching a film on Kashmir, nevertheless it was Shikara. The film was launched in 2020. Vidhu Vinod Chopra Movies, which produced Shikara, had organised a particular screening for the veteran chief. His response was captured and uploaded on their Instagram page on Feb 7, 2020. Vidhu Vinod Chopra, the director of the film and Mr. Advani’s daughter Pratibha are additionally seen within the clip.

Mr. Adityanath too turned emotional, however the incident occurred in October 2017, throughout an occasion to honour martyrs in Gorakhpur.

Reality examine: False

Deleted scene for Kashmir Recordsdata?

A video clip of a person carrying cranium cap talking in opposition to the Indian Military and the Union authorities, and their alleged atrocities on Kashmiris is being circulated as a deleted clip from the film.

A reverse picture search on a screengrab of the particular person talking led us to a Youtube video posted on September 3, 2019. The person has uploaded a Tiktok video in Youtube. We additionally discovered a Times of India article dated March 17, 2020 stating that the capturing, which was supposed to start that week, has been postponed on account of COVID-19. An article in Tribune mentioned that the primary schedule of capturing started in December 2020 in Mussorie.

Reality examine: False

Assault on Muslim man influenced by movie?

A clip of a girl assaulting a Muslim man repeatedly in a prepare, forcing him to fall at her toes and even threatening to kill him, has been shared on Fb with the declare that the incident was influenced by  The Kashmir Recordsdata.

A reverse picture search proved in any other case. Our investigation led us to a report on the incident by  The Wire. It was dated October 19, 2021 – 5 months earlier than the movie hit the screens. In accordance with the report, the person was assaulted for allegedly pushing the girl whereas passing by the coach. The lady was recognized as Madhu Sharma, a Hindutva chief linked to controversial seer Yati Narsinghanand, who was recently arrested for making a vitriolic speech in opposition to Muslim s at a spiritual conclave in Haridwar (He has since been launched on bail). 

Reality examine: Deceptive

Morphed placard used to hail film

A picture of a person seemingly holding up a placard stating, “Kashmir Recordsdata in not a film. It’s a wake-up name for Hindus,” is doing the rounds on social media. The picture additionally seems to have been taken someplace exterior India.

Utilizing a mixture of reverse picture and key phrase search, we discovered that the placard had been morphed. The original picture had this assertion: “Cease utilizing group pics on your courting profile.”

The particular person featured within the picture is Seth Phillips, whose thought of holding up cardboard indicators that includes pithy remarks about a variety of up to date points struck a chord with the general public within the U.S. He was additionally profiled by  Forbes.

He repeatedly posts photographs of his distinctive type of protest on his Instagram account, named dudewithsign.

Reality examine: Manipulated content material

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.